The main pavilion of the Marina with a “warehouse ceiling” today, with the project signed by architect Eduardo Mondolfo (built in 2016), radically altering Amaro Machado’s original proposal. © Agência Estado, 2016.
A Listed Public Heritage or Shopping Mall?

Latent Conflicts at the Lagoa Rowing Stadium

Authors

Additional Files

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52200/docomomo.71.06

Keywords:

Modern Movement, built heritage, listed building, Preservation, Adaptive Reuse

Abstract

The recognition of 20th-century architecture in Brazil is still a field restricted to specialists, which makes the remaining assets of this collection susceptible to defacement or even destruction. The designation of the Lagoa Rowing Stadium as a historic landmark by the city of Rio de Janeiro gives us the possibility of reflecting on the existing dispute between the public interest, protected by the listing in 2005, versus the financial voracity of private groups toward the asset in question. Grotesque defacement was undertaken starting in 2003 with the approval of the State and city administrations, including the intent to turn the sports complex into a business complex, thereby distorting the original proposal from the 1950s.

How to Cite

Alves e Silva, R. (2024). A Listed Public Heritage or Shopping Mall? Latent Conflicts at the Lagoa Rowing Stadium. Docomomo Journal, (71), 40–46. https://doi.org/10.52200/docomomo.71.06

Published

2024-11-14

Plaudit

Author Biography

Renato Alves e Silva, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro

is an architect of the technical staff of UFRJ, Master in Preservation of Cultural Heritage by Iphan, PhD in Architecture by PPGAU-UFF. He is a member of the Research Groups “City as a Document of Urban History” (PPGAU-UFF) and “Arquimuseus” (Proarq-UFRJ). Acting mainly with the theme of preservation of the architectural heritage of the 20th century in Brazil.

References

HIME, V. (2003, February 4). [Letter addressed to the friend ‘Zezé Barros’ endorsing the listing of the Rowing Stadium]. Listing Process 12/000.343/03 (p. 26), Rio de Janeiro, Prefeitura da Cidade do Rio de Janeiro.

IRPH (2003). Listing process number 12/000.343/03, Listing of the Lagoa Rowing Stadium, Rio de Janeiro City Hall/ Document Collection of the Subgerência de Cadastro e Pesquisa do IRPH – Office of Registration and Research of the IRPH –.

LIMA, E. F. W. (2003, August 20). [Excerpt of the opinion submitted to the Conselho Municipal de Proteção do Patrimônio Cultural do Rio de Janeiro (CMPC) – Municipal Council for Protection of Cultural Heritage of Rio de Janeiro]. Listing process 12/000.343/03 (pp. 29-30), IRPH, Rio de Janeiro.

NIEMEYER, O. (2003, February 7). [Text handwritten by the architect expressing his opinion contrary to the possibility of changing the purpose of the Lagoa Rowing Stadium by the municipality of Rio]. Listing Process number 12/000.343/03 (pp. 4-6), Rio de Janeiro, Prefeitura da Cidade do Rio de Janeiro.

RIVERA, P. & Moreira, C. (2003, February 7). Justifications for Listing the Lagoa Rowing Stadium as a Heritage Site. Listing Process number 12/000.343/03 (pp. 4-6), Rio de Janeiro, Prefeitura da Cidade do Rio de Janeiro.

SILVA, R. A. (2021). Equipamento público tombado ou centro comercial? As disputas latentes no Estádio de Remo da Lagoa. In: 4th ICOMOS Brasil Scientific Symposium, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.