„Machine“. Arch. Alfred Kastner, USA, Stamford. © Projects, 1931 (without page numbers). “1931p.” Design team from “Ukrbudob’ednannya”, Ukraine, Kharkiv. © Projects, 1931 (without page numbers).
Kharkiv International Competition

The Apogee of the Soviet Architectural Avant-Garde

Authors

Downloads

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52200/docomomo.70.08

Keywords:

international architectural competitions, theater buildings, modernism of the 1920s-1930s, history of Ukrainian architecture

Abstract

One of the sides of a large study dedicated to the forgotten international competition of 1930 for the Project of the State Ukrainian Theater of Mass Musical Action in Kharkiv is touched upon in this article. Its purpose is the reconstruction of the competition events, identifying the features of the process of their organization. The competition attracted a record number of foreign contestants not only from many European countries, but also from other continents (from the USA and Japan). Why did it generate such widespread interest? Which famous architects took part in it? Who evaluated the projects and according to what criteria were the awards distributed? The author of this article is looking for answers to these questions. The problems of the research are due to the fact that the originals of the competition projects have not survived, and their photocopies and preparatory sketches are scattered in the archives of many countries. Information about the competition and its contestants is scarce and is documented in different languages: Ukrainian, German, French, Russian, Japanese, English, Croatian, Swedish. Only painstaking gathering, meaningful and comparative analysis of textual and graphical information obtained during the study, allows the author to reproduce the course of the competition, to reveal its significance for the development of architecture in Ukraine and for the world Modern Movement. The article analyses the methods that ensured a high level of organization of the competition and an open, unbiased assessment of its results. The distribution of prizes and the authors of the winning projects are also listed. The Kharkiv competition took place at a crucial period for the Soviet avant-garde: 1930-1931 were the last years of its heyday, after which it was banned and persecuted for many years. That is why it is so important to collect these lost puzzles of architectural history.

How to Cite

Smolenska, S. (2024). Kharkiv International Competition: The Apogee of the Soviet Architectural Avant-Garde. Docomomo Journal, (70), 60–69. https://doi.org/10.52200/docomomo.70.08

Published

2024-04-15

Plaudit

Author Biography

Svitlana Smolenska, Kherson State Agrarian and Economic University

was born and received her architectural education in Kharkiv/UA, defended her PhD thesis in 1993 (Scientific Research Institute of Theory and History of Architecture and Urban Planning, Moscow) and received her Sc.D. diploma in 2017 (Lviv Polytechnic National University, Ukraine). She is an expert of ISC20C, a member of the national ICOMOS (Ukraine), of the Union of Journalists of Ukraine, a guest researcher at TH OWL (Detmold), financed by a scholarship of the Volkswagen Foundation (2022-2024). Her professional interests are: urban environment research, architecture and town planning of the 20th century as cultural heritage. She is a professor at the Department of Construction, Architecture and Design, Kherson State Agrarian and Economic University/UA.

References

DE FEO, V. (1963). URSS architettura 1917-1936. Editori Riuniti.

CHAN-MAGOMEDOW, S. O. (1983). Pioniere der sowjetischen Architektur. Löcker Verlag Wien, Berlin.

Wikipedia (2021). Jöran Curman. https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jöran_Curman Accessed June 25, 2023.

La Cité & Tekhne (1931). Volume 10(2), October, p. 37.

LINDSTRÖM, Sune (1906 - 1989) [sv]. KulturNav (2022). https://kulturnav.org/058c683d-6910-46c8-b5bf-d2cdb6b2821d Accessed June 27, 2023.

Programme du concours international pour un Théâtre d’Etat Ukrainien de scènes musicales de masses de 4.000 places, à Kharkov (1933). In L’Architecture Vivante, 40, pp. 23-50.

RICHTER (1931). Wettbewerb Theater Charkow. In Die Baugilde, 20, pp. 1562-1588.

SMOLENSKA, S. (2019). Avant-garde architecture and art of the 1920s–1930s in Ukraine and European modernism: interpenetration methods. In Architectus, 3(59), pp. 11-18. DOI: 10.5277/arc190302 https://dbc.wroc.pl/Content/74458/59_02.pdf

SMOLENSKA, S. (2023). The modernist administrative centre in Kharkiv (Ukraine) as cultural heritage: from the early 1920s to 2022. In: Kilian Heck und Aleksandra Lipińska (Hrsg.): Als der Krieg kam … Neue Beiträge zur Kunst in der Ukraine. Heidelberg: arthistoricum, рр. 76–104. https://doi.org/10.11588/arthistoricum.1227.c17105

SMOLENSKA, S., NÄGELKE, H.D. (2023). Architect Hans Poelzig: a project for Ukraine. In Budownictwo i Architektura 22(3), pp. 59-72. DOI: 10.35784/bud-arch.4241 https://ph.pollub.pl/index.php/bia/article/view/4241/4244

UMEMIYA, H. (2022) The International Competition for the State Ukrainian Theatre (1930). Application proposals from Japan. In DOCOMOMO Journal, 67, pp. 48-54.

ЛІНЕЦЬКИЙ О. В., РУДНИК К. А., ШЕСТОПАЛ М. М. (1931). Міжнародний конкурс на проект Державного українського театру масового музичного дійства на 4000 місць у Харкові. In Будівництво, [LINETSKY А. V., RUDNIK K. A., SHESTOPAL M. M. (1931). Mizhnarodnyi konkurs na proekt Derzhavnoho ukrainskoho teatru masovoho muzychnoho diistva na 4000 mists u Kharkovi/ International competition for the project of the State Ukrainian Theater of Mass Musical Action for 4,000 seats in Kharkiv. In Budivnitstvo/Construction], 7—8, pp. 32 -51. (In Ukrainian).

Програма міжнародного конкурсу на проект державного українського театру масового музичного дійства на 4000 місць в м. Харкові (1930). [Prohrama mizhnarodnoho konkursu na proekt derzhavnoho ukrainskoho teatru masovoho muzychnoho diistva na 4000 mists v m. Kharkovi/ Program of the international competition for the project of the State Ukrainian Theater of Mass Musical Action for 4,000 seats in the city of Kharkiv]. Kharkiv. (In Ukrainian, Russian, German, English and French).

Проекти міжнародного конкурсу державного українського театру масового музичного дійства на 4000 місць в м. Харкові. Альбом фотографій для голови секції мистецтв тов. Петренко О.І. (1931). [Proekty mizhnarodnoho konkursu derzhavnoho ukrainskoho teatru masovoho muzychnoho diistva na 4000 mists v m. Kharkovi. Albom fotohrafii dlia holovy sektsii mystetstv tov. Petrenko O.I./ Projects of the international competition of the Ukrainian State Theater of Mass Musical Action for 4,000 seats in the city of Kharkiv. A photo album for the head of the arts section, Comrade Petrenko O.I.]. Kharkiv (In Ukrainian).

СЕДЛЯР В. (1931). Міжнародний конкурс на проєкт державного театру масового музичного дійства на 4000 місць у Харкові. In Радянський театр [SEDLYAR V. (1931). Mizhnarodnyi konkurs na proiekt derzhavnoho teatru masovoho muzychnoho diistva na 4000 mists u Kharkovi / International competition for the project of the State Theater of Mass Musical Action for 4,000 seats in Kharkiv. In Radianskyi teatr/Soviet theatre], 3, pp. 21-23. (In Ukrainian).