MODERN WORLD HERITAGE

Reflections on Ukraine

Authors

  • Thomas Flierl
  • Jörg Haspel

Downloads

Keywords:

World Heritage, modern heritage, tentative list, infrastructure, Ukraine, World Heritage, modern heritage, tentative list, infrastructure, Ukraine

Abstract

The article reflects on the status of modern World Heritage sites in general and in particular related to Ukraine, and the specific typologies of infrastructure and modern urban planning – both closely related to each other. The current war and the disastrous destruction of urban and civil infrastructure have again raised the question of its public perception, official recognition and national and international protection. Next to the internationally known Derzhprom complex, the cnstruction of Dneprostroj, the Dnipro Hydroelectric Station (DneproGES/DniproHES), the erection of a new industrial combine in direct proximity to it, and the new socialist city Sotsgorod—known as Zaporizhzhia—are impressive examples of urbanization and testimonies of the 20th century that need to be protected.

How to Cite

Flierl, T., & Haspel, J. (2022). MODERN WORLD HERITAGE: Reflections on Ukraine. Docomomo Journal, (67). Retrieved from https://docomomojournal.com/index.php/journal/article/view/544

Published

2022-12-12

Author Biographies

Thomas Flierl

Thomas Flierl (1957), freelance cultural scientist, architectural historian and publicist, since 2007 Chair of the board of the Hermann Henselmann Foundation and the Max Lingner Foundation in Berlin. Studied philosophy and aesthetics at Humboldt University in Berlin, earning his doctorate in the Department of Aesthetics at Humboldt University (1985). Member of the Berlin House of Representatives (1995-98), City councilor for construction in Berlin-Mitte (1998-2000), and Berlin’s senator for culture and science (2002-06). He is a member of the Institute for History and Theory of Architecture and Planning at the Bauhaus-University Weimar and of the Scientific advisory board of the der Ernst-May-Society e.V. in Frankfurt/Main.

Jörg Haspel

JÖRG HASPEL (1953), former State Curator of the Landesdenkmalamt Berlin. Studied architecture and urban planning at Stuttgart University and history of art and empirical cultural studies at Tübingen University (1972-81), Preservationist at the Senate Department of Cultural Affairs at the Hanseatic City of Hamburg (1982-91), State Curator and Director of the Berlin Heritage Conservation Authority (1992-2018). President of ICOMOS Germany (2012-2021) and funding member of the International Scientific Committee of 20th Century Heritage of ICOMOS (ISC20C) in 2005. He is Chair of the board of the German Foundation of Monument Protection since 2014 and Honorary Professor at Technical University of Berlin.

References

CHAN-MAGOMEDOV, S. (1996). Arhitektura sovetskogo avangarda, Kniga pervaja, Glava 7. Mnogoobrazie koncepciĭ formy, 13. Konkurs na proekt zdanija turbinnogo zala Dneprogjesa (protivoborstvo konstruktivizma i neorenessansnoĭ shkoly) [The Architecture of the Soviet Avant-Garde, vol. 1, chap. 7, The Diversity of Conceptions of Form, 13. The Competition for the Building of the Turbine Hall of DneproGES (The Confrontation of Constructivism and the Neo-Renaissance School)], Moscow.

DÖMPKE S. (Ed.) (2022). Special Report - World Heritage Sites Damaged by War in Ukraine, In: World Heritage Watch Report 2022, Berlin 2022, pp. 9-12, https://world-heritage-watch.org/content/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/2022-Report-WHW-final.pdf, Accessed Nov. 19, 2022.

DOUET, J. (2018). The Water Industry as World Heritage. TICCIH Thematic Papers.

https://www.academia.edu/39018279/The_Water_Industry_as_World_Heritage. Accessed Nov. 12, 2022.

FLIERL, T. (2018), “‘The Fettered Dnieper’ or ‘The Socialist Assault on Nature’”. In: Constructing the world – art

and economy 1919-1939. Edited by Eckhart J. Gillen and Ulrike Lorenz, Bielefeld/Berlin: Kerber Verlag, pp. 290-300.

HASPEL, J. , Staroste, H. (2011). Das Erbe der Elektropolis Berlin. In: Weltkulturerbe und Europäisches Kulturerbe-Siegel in Deutschland. Potentiale und Nominirungsvorschläge, ICOMOS-Journals of the German National Committee Vol. 51, Berlin, ICOMOS, pp. 74-78.

HASPEL, J., Petzet, M., Zalivako, A. & Ziesemer J. (eds.) (2007). The Soviet Heritage and European Modernism

(Heritage at Risk Special 2006), ICOMOS: Berlin, Hendrik Bäßler Verlag.

HENKET, H.-J. (2014). The Modern Movement and the World Heritage List. The DOCOMOMO tentative list by Hubert-Jan Henket, dec. 1998 cf. In: Liu, K., Toestoes, A., (Eds.), Docomomo International 1988-2012: Key Papers in Modern Architectural Heritage Conservation, Bejing: China Architecture & Building Press https://docomomo.com/books/b-kpmahc/

ICOMOS (2013). Sozialistischer Realismus und Sozialistische Moderne.Welterbevorschläge aus Mittel- und Osteuropa / Socialist Realism and Socialist Modernism. World Heritage Proposals from Central and Eastern Europe, ICOMOS – Journals of the German National Committee LVIII, Berlin: hendrik Bäßler-Verlag, https://www.icomos.de/admin/ckeditor/plugins/alphamanager/uploads/pdf/Heft_LVIII.pdf, Accessed Nov. 19, 2022.

ICOMOS (2019). Moderne neu denken. Architektur und Städtebau des 20. Jahrhunderts / Rethinking Modernity. Architecture and Urban Planning of the 20th Century, ICOMOS – Journals of the German National Committee LXIX), Stuttgart: Karl Krämer Verlag, https://www.icomos.de/icomos/pdf/icomosmoderne-neu-denken_web_5nov2019.pdf, Accessed Nov. 19, 2022.

JOKILEHTO, J. (2004). The World Heritage List: Filling the Gaps - an Action Plan for the Future. An Analysis by ICOMOS, February 2004. In: Monuments and Sites XII, compiled by Jukka Jokilehto, with contributions from Henry Cleere, Susan Denyer and Michael Petzet; file:///C:/Users/jkh/AppData/Local/Temp/activity-590-1-1.pdf

KRAVCHUK, P. P. (2017). Shestoj poselok v Zaporozh’e i problema rabochego rasselenja [The sixth settlement in Zaporozh’e and the problem of workers’ settlement], In: Muzejnij visnik № 17, Zaporizhzhia, pp. 147-178.

KRAVCHUK, P. P. (2018). Dneprostroj v bor’be za puti razvitija sovetskoj arkhitektury. Stenogramma obshchestvennoj prosmotra proektov dneprovskoj gidrostancii [Dnieperstroj in the struggle for the development of Soviet architecture. Transcript of the public examination of the Dnieper hydroelectric power plant projects], In: Muzejnij visnik № 18, Zaporizhzhia, pp. 129-140.

KRAVCHUK, P. P. (2023). Zaporizhzhia. The Socialist City as a Cultural Model, In: Mihaylov, V., Mikhail Ilchenko, M. (Eds.), Post-Utopian Spaces. Transforming and Re-Evaluation Icons of Socialist Modernism, London/New York: Routledge, pp. 58-80.

MARSDEN, S., Spearritt, P. (2021). The Twentieth-Century Historic Thematic Framework: A Tool for Assessing Heritage Places. With contributions from Leo Schmidt, Sheridan Burke, Gail Ostergren, Jeff Cody, and Chandler McCoy. Los Angeles: Getty Conservation Institute.

https://hdl.handle.net/10020/gci_pubs_historic_thematic_framework_tool. Accessed Oct. 30, 2022.

TOSTOES, A. (Ed.) (2022). Modern Heritage. Restoration, Renovation, Reuse. Berlin: Birkhäuser.

VAN OERS, R., Haraguchi, S. (Eds.) (2003). Identification and Documentation of Modern Heritage, World Heritage Papers, No. 5, Paris, UNESCO World Heritage Centre.

WOLFSCHMIDT, G. (Ed.) (2009). Cultural Heritage of Astronomical Observatories. From Classical Astronomy to Modern Astrophysics, Proceedings of the International ICOMOS Symposium in Hamburg, October 14–17, 2008. ICOMOS – International Council on Monuments and Sites. Berlin: hendrik Bäßler-Verlag, https://www.fhsev.de/Wolfschmidt/buch/Icomos09-Inhalt.pdf, Accessed Nov. 19, 2022.