Should Le Corbusier’s E.1027 murals be considered as “historical monuments”?

Authors

  • Agnès Cailliau

Downloads

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52200/60.A.KRJNWI0A

Keywords:

Modern Movement, Modern architecture, Modern housing

Abstract

Le Corbusier’s murals in E.1027, the famous house designed by Eileen Gray, have been maintained and restored as “historical monuments”. I subscribe to a different view, and shall express it from three perspectives: • a legal and administrative dimension: only Eileen Gray’s E.1027 is designated a Historical Monument. The murals are not covered by this classification. • an artistic point of view: Le Corbusier’s murals are detrimental to the original state of the architectural work and to the spirit of the house, they are discordant. The murals, by their mere presence, endanger the architectural work. • a physical/technical angle: Le Corbusier’s murals themselves are in physical danger.

How to Cite

Cailliau, A. (2019). Should Le Corbusier’s E.1027 murals be considered as “historical monuments”?. Docomomo Journal, (60), 84–88. https://doi.org/10.52200/60.A.KRJNWI0A

Published

2019-07-01

Author Biography

Agnès Cailliau

(b. France, 1951) Graduated from École de Chaillot, and from ICCROM (International Centre for the Study of the Preservation and Restoration of Cultural Property), former “Architecte-Urbaniste en chef de l’Etat”, Agnès Cailliau led a dual career as a teacher in schools of architecture (Lille, Rouen) and as an “architecte du patrimoine” [heritage architect]. She chaired docomomo France from 2007 to 2017.

References

BENTON, Tim, Le Corbusier Peintre à Cap Martin, Paris, Editions du patrimoine Centre des monuments nationaux, 2015.

Collectif Le Corbusier Ultimes pensées / Derniers projets – 1960/1965, Massilia 2013, Fondation Le Corbusier et Edition Imbernon, mars 2014.

GRAY, Eileen; BADOVICI, Jean, “E.1027 Maison en bord de mer”, L’Architecture vivante, Hiver, Paris, Albert Morancé, 1929, réédition Marseille, Edition Imbernon, 2006.

WANG, Wilfried; ADAM, Peter (Eds), O’Neil Ford Monograph 7: E.1027, Eileen Gray (1926-1929), Berlin, The University of Texas at Austin & Center for American Architecture and Design and Ernst J. Wasmuth Verlag, 2018.